Up-and-coming Catholic commentator Alexander Poe nails his colours to the mast on the ‘Pope Question’, and names The WM Review as an influence.
(WM Round-Up) – Alexander Poe – a convert from Evangelical Protestantism, philosophy master’s student, and up-and-coming Catholic commentator has publicly stated his conclusion that the post-conciliar claimants to the papacy do not hold the office of St Peter.
Poe, who is soon to be starting as Integrity Magazine's Video Director, made the statement on X on 19 November, in reply to a Twitter user who had pressed him on the question.
He followed it up with a longer essay on his Substack, Poe Choice of Words, titled The Elephant in the Room.
Here are the question and answer in full:
Jozef Struhliarsky: Dear Alexander! Are you a sedevacantist or not? Why are you evading answering this question? If nothing, could you at least in charity answer me that you will not disclose it to me? I am begging you. U think I ask decently. Thank you. May God bless you and your family.
Alexander Poe: I receive this question, in one form or another, multiple times a week, so here are some thoughts in response:
Just because I am a public figure with a platform does not mean I owe anyone a response. I can, and will, use prudence to choose not to answer certain questions depending on their context.
As it pertains to this one in particular, I do not think it is any big secret that I have serious doubts about the current hierarchy claiming to exercise the authority of Christ in Rome. I have made video after video professing this view quite explicitly.
The fundamental issue is that Our Lord established His Catholic Church on the rock of St. Peter, and guaranteed that the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. In 553, the Second Council of Constantinople reiterated this and added that “the gates of hell…[are] the deadly tongues of heretics.” Thus, heresy cannot possibly prevail against Christ’s Church. St. Peter, the rock, is the guardian of the Catholic Faith precisely insofar as he defends it against heresy. If the Roman Pontiff were to profess heresy in the very exercise of his office, it would be clear he does not truly hold that office, as the very nature of his role is to ensure orthodoxy.
This orthodoxy is guaranteed by the Holy Ghost, Who is the immutable Spirit of Truth, and so Catholic doctrine cannot undergo a substantial change which contradicts a truth it previously professed. This would mean that, either previously or now, the Spirit of Truth has inspired error, as two contradicting “truths” necessarily implies one or the other cannot possibly be true. This brings us to Vatican II.
Vatican II teaches multiple “truths” which were previously condemned by the Catholic Church as heresy. I have outlined these contradictions over the course of several presentations at this point which together constitute tens of thousands of words and hours of video. You can find a recap of just one of these errors (viz., religious liberty) in the replies to this post below.
The problem is that every single claimant to the papacy since the Second Vatican Council has officially upheld and professed its errors as legitimate and binding. Since, as has already been mentioned, Christ established His Church on the rock of St. Peter and guaranteed that the “deadly tongues of heretics” would not prevail against it, we must necessarily conclude that these men do not hold the office of St. Peter. It is the only way to protect the Church’s indefectibility.
I am not saying anything new here, but to acknowledge this reality directly in response to this question will almost certainly call upon me many names and labels. That is fine. I do not care, and I will simply go on about my business in pursuit of and in fidelity to the truth.
In The Elephant in the Room, Poe thanks three people whose work helped him reach his conclusion.
The first was Bishop Donald Sanborn of the Roman Catholic Institute and Most Holy Trinity Seminary.
The second was Alexander Petersen, of The Journal of American Reform and Integrity Magazine.
The third was yours truly and The WM Review. He said:
“The third is S.D. Wright from The WM Review, whose impressively in-depth theological essays are both academic and accessible. For anyone new to the topic, I highly recommend his “Zero Marks” which is very long, but certainly worth anyone’s time who is interested in approaching this topic with the seriousness it deserves. Please consider supporting him however you can.”
We are grateful for his kind words, and delighted to hear about the positive effect which Zero Marks has had.
Some of the themes which Poe considered decisive are also addressed in Spotless and Unsullied, the follow-up to Zero Marks. You can find all the parts of the series – along with the executive summary of Zero Marks – here:
‘Radically insufficient’ – Reply to Fr Crean on the Church’s visibility
‘Zero Marks’ – Why the Conciliar/Synodal Church is not the Catholic Church
‘Spotless and Unsullied’ – Indefectibility and the Extended Vacancy
Around the same time that we published Spotless and Unsullied, Poe himself published an accessible video on the same subject.
This video has been seen over 53,000 times, and Poe’s YouTube channel itself has nearly 23,000 subscribers – indicating the significant audience which he reaches.
He also recently published an interview with Bishop Sanborn:
It is most edifying to see Poe take this step. “Declaring” (more on that verb here) that one has concluded the Holy See to be vacant can be a brave thing to do – especially if one has an existing “career” in the Catholic world. To say what he has said is to risk that audience – as well as one’s livelihood.
However, the dominance of the online “Recognise and Resist” and “Rethinking the Papacy” movement is ending. Fewer and fewer young Catholics are interested in the totems and taboos presented of the older generations – be they religious or political.
Indeed, it was most interesting to see Poe refer specifically to Zero Marks as influencing his thinking on this matter. That particular work was written as part of a resposne to Fr Thomas Crean’s article A City Set on a Hill Cannot Be Hidden, which Dr Peter Kwasniewski rather risibly called a “definitive rebuttal of sedevacantism, at the level of first principles.” Evidently, not everybody shares Kwasniewski’s estimation of this article.
Try as they may, the online R&R advocates who cling to such positions, in the face of all reasoned arguments to the contrary, will either continue to lose ground, or be forced to withdraw from public engagement on the relevant matters.
In the meantime, we encourage others to consider the issue carefully, and to follow Poe’s example if they are convinced, or to continue thinking and praying diligently if they are not. The following article may be of assistance:
As many have remarked: all the power that these men have depends on the pretence that they are true Popes. One of the most meaningful things that many of us can do for the good of the Church is to state the truth openly: that they are not.
See also Poe’s statement:
Afterword
Our friend Theo Howard, of The Two Cities Podcast's Substack, responded to Poe’s statement as follows:
Howard is not one of the “online R&R advocates” to whom I mentioned above. However, there are three points to make in response to this.
The first is that Dignitatis Humanae is indeed binding. It presents its teaching as based on the “dignity of the human person” as “known both through the revealed Word of God and by reason itself.” Its language indicates the definitive nature of its teaching, which belies the claim raised. This is recognised by both those who accept and reject its teaching – including, for example, Alan Fimister:
Indeed, the claim that it is not binding is untenable
The second point is that, while Theo may be correct in noting that “no one has been excommunicated for rejecting religious liberty”, this is beside the point. The failure to enforce adherence to this doctrine does not undermine the definitiveness or binding nature of what is found in Dignitatis Humanae; it simply shows that the alleged “authorities” of the Conciliar/Synodal Church are negligent.
The third point, to which Poe himself refers in his answer, is that the Church’s infallibility and indefectibility do not only preclude errors being enforced, but also the definitive proposition of heresy or error in the exercise of his magisterium regardless of what comes after it. One cannot get the post-conciliar claimants to the papacy “off the hook” by saying that their “magisterial errors” were not enforced.
This is addressed further in Spotless and Unsullied.
Once again, Poe has taken a brave step here. Please go and read his article and, if you are able to do so, support him in his work:
HELP KEEP THE WM REVIEW ONLINE WITH WM+!
As we expand The WM Review we would like to keep providing free articles for everyone.
Our work takes a lot of time and effort to produce. If you have benefitted from it please do consider supporting us financially.
A subscription gets you access to our exclusive WM+ material, and helps ensure that we can keep writing and sharing free material for all.
You can see what readers are saying over at our Testimonials page.
And you can visit The WM Review Shop for our ‘Lovely Mugs’ and more.
(We make our WM+ material freely available to clergy, priests and seminarians upon request. Please subscribe and reply to the email if this applies to you.)
Subscribe to WM+ now to make sure you always receive our material. Thank you!
Read Next:
‘Radically insufficient’ – Reply to Fr Crean on the Church’s visibility
‘Zero Marks’ – Why the Conciliar/Synodal Church is not the Catholic Church
‘Spotless and Unsullied’ – Indefectibility and the Extended Vacancy
Follow on Twitter, YouTube and Telegram:
Twitter (The WM Review)





