The WM Review

The WM Review

'Radically insufficient' – Reply to Fr Crean on the Church's visibility, Part I

Fr Thomas Crean appeals to the visibility of the Church as a means of refuting those who posit an extended vacancy of the Holy See. But this treatment is radically insufficient.

S.D. Wright's avatar
S.D. Wright
Feb 16, 2026
Photo by Kristijan Arsov on Unsplash. As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases through our Amazon links. See also The WM Review Shop.

Fr Thomas Crean appeals to the visibility of the Church as a means of refuting those who posit an extended vacancy of the Holy See. But this treatment is radically insufficient.

Fr Thomas Crean OP’s article

Fr Thomas Crean OP has contributed an article to Pelican+ on “The Perpetual Visibility of the Catholic Church Under the Pope.”

However, this article is about more than just the visibility of the Church: the doctrinal exposition is specifically ordered towards an attempted refutation of “sedevacantism” – that is, the thesis which holds that the Holy See has been vacant since some time between 1958 and 1965.

Professor Peter Kwasniewski, who also published the article on his Tradition and Sanity website, advertised it as “a definitive rebuttal of sedevacantism, at the level of first principles.”

X avatar for @DrKwasniewski
Peter Kwasniewski@DrKwasniewski
Today at Tradition & Sanity, Fr. Thomas Crean writes a definitive rebuttal of sedevacantism, at the level of first principles.
app.pelicanplus.com
A City Set on a Hill Cannot Be Hidden | Pelican+
4:24 PM · Feb 12, 2026 · 9.18K Views

9 Replies · 7 Reposts · 20 Likes

However, Fr Crean’s treatment of these “first principles” is radically insufficient.

Fr Crean is considerably more gracious towards those who hold to this thesis than others who enter the lists against it. He also makes many points with which we “sedevacantists” would agree. However, it is regrettable that, at certain key moments, he both misunderstands the arguments made by “sedevacantists,” and fails to appreciate the degree to which his own position violates the true notion of the Church’s visibility.

Fr Crean’s principal failure here is that what he treats as needing to be perpetually visibile is a mere legal structure, whereas the Church’s visibility entails more than this; he also treats the visibility of the Church as discernible in the papacy alone.


This article is for subscribers. Subscribe now for FREE:

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from The WM Review.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 The WM Review · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.