4 Comments
User's avatar
John Lewis's avatar

If it wasn’t published, how can we attribute it to Pius XI?

Expand full comment
S.D. Wright's avatar

I hear your point, but it's through a turn of phrase. This is not a magisterial document, to be sure.

Expand full comment
S.D. Wright's avatar

By a figure of speech. But you are right, it is not like it is magisterial but simply lost. It is not magisterial.

Expand full comment
John Lewis's avatar

To be honest I don’t think you should be promoting Will Tucker or this podcast.

The episode on annulments was highly critical of teaching from Pius XII and basically accused him of teaching error.

I find it on the whole to be dangerous to be dangerous to the faith, notwithstanding the appearance of yourself and the founder of Sister Lucy Truth on the podcast.

Expand full comment